HOME VIDEO REVIEWS
Matthew Goltz
4 April 2005
Rating Scale: **** (Robert DeNiro) *** (Robert Redford) ** (Robert
Downey) * (Robert McGinty)
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Season One)
Being a fan of both theatrical Ghost In The Shell films,
I was very eager to see the television series and it did not disappoint.
The emphasis in the series is much more on the action-side, veering rather
far off from the silence and reflection of Ghost in the Shell
2: Innocence (which is so perfect it would be hard for most
films to match it). While it occasionally deals with higher minded concepts
in a breezier manner, it stands tall as an episodic adventure show with
extremely well defined characters and some wonderful animation, a combo
of cel work and CGI. Add to the above some cute Tachikoma robotank
antics (the blue, childlike weaponry that serves as a sort of show mascot)
and some insights into our beloved heroes (hints of romance, here and
there) and you have something near-perfect and truly special.
***1/2
Samurai Champloos (Episodes 1-17)
Mugen, Jin and Fuu -- two masterless samurai and a young woman they follow
-- make a fun team in this rousing and intense anime series. Part Akira
Kurosawa, part hip-hop and what a combo. Shinichiro Watanabe (Cowboy Bebop)
has fashioned an involving show that keeps the laughs and artful animation
coming quickly and furiously. I only wish I'd known that there were 26
episodes before I'd found the 17 episode boxset. Here's hoping I can soon
see the rest...
***
Rubber's Lover
Largely a waste of time for anyone seeking coherence or entertainment.
A mix-hash of Tetsuo: The Iron Man and an S&M
Fetish film, this noisefest has an underground, experimental vibe that
isn't nearly as interesting or exciting as it sounds. The last act is
comprised primarily of thirty minutes of screaming and blackened bloodshed.
It has a certain kinship to Akira at one specific moment, though that
doesn't necessarily make it any more interesting. This might be you're
thing, but it sure isn't mine.
*
Sword of Doom
Viewed just in time for the upcoming Criterion Collection DVD,
this old-fashioned samurai revenge tale gives us a little of the old ultra-violence
and a powerful performance by lead villain Tatsuya Nakadai. In his handful
of scenes, Toshiro Mifune impresses us with regal grandeur. The conclusion,
though unconventionally presented, has a fierceness that will likely stick
with you. Here's hoping Criterion's edition can fill in some of the blanks.
***
Purple Butterfly
It's an interesting story involving the Japanese occupation of Shanghai
in the time of Yamamoto and the Chinese rebels fighting it, though espionage
tales involving mistaken identity, nationalism, tragic deaths and love
triangles just should not be this dragged out. Chaotic action sequences
come up every thirty minutes or so but are surrounded by pensive, "emotional"
moments where the actors just stare at each other or off into space as
if in another world. Zhang Ziyi, remarkably beautiful even even dressed-down
and shell-shocked, has her moments in scenes involving quiet plotting,
though she's never quite believable as the take-charge assassin type under
these circumstances. The film has some effective moments, such as when
an Innocent Man is mistaken for a Revolutionary Contact. His character
gets our greatest sympathy through the film as his situation forces him
to becomes a sort of wandering time bomb of a man, too far gone for anything
but a terrible fate. It's a film of interest for it's intentions, rather
than the way those intentions are presented.
**1/2